SmallBizGenius Analysis

Catholiccompany.com, a retailer of Catholic goods, receives mixed reviews. While some customers praise the quality and beauty of their purchases, others report issues with shipping, customer service, and product quality, leading to an overall rating that suggests caution.

Category Breakdown

Scores based on analysis of 96 recent reviews

Shipping and Delivery

4.0/10

Many reviewers report issues with shipping, including delays, lost packages, and lack of communication. Several customers mention receiving no tracking information or updates on their orders, and some report that items arrived late, even when they paid for expedited shipping.

30 reviews mention this

Customer Service

3.5/10

A significant number of reviewers express dissatisfaction with customer service, citing unresponsiveness, difficulty contacting representatives, and unhelpful support when issues arise. Some customers report that their emails and calls went unanswered, while others describe interactions with bots or unhelpful representatives.

28 reviews mention this

Product Quality

6.0/10

Several reviewers complain about the poor quality of products, stating that items received were not as advertised or were damaged upon arrival. Some customers mention discrepancies in product descriptions, such as medals not being sterling silver as claimed, while others report issues with engraving quality and overall craftsmanship.

25 reviews mention this

Returns and Refunds

4.5/10

Several reviewers express frustration with the return process, noting that they were required to pay for return shipping even when the issue was the company's fault. Some customers also report receiving only partial refunds or having difficulty obtaining refunds for damaged or undelivered items.

15 reviews mention this

Product Satisfaction

8.0/10

Many customers are pleased with the beauty and quality of specific items, particularly religious items like the Divine Mercy Triptych and engraved Bibles. These reviewers often express satisfaction with their purchases and appreciate the unique selection offered by the company.

20 reviews mention this

Pros & Cons

What Customers Love

Wide selection of Catholic items Mentioned 10x
"The Catholic Company has a wonderful selection of Catholic items. I loved how the site was so user friendly."
Some customers find the products beautiful and well-made Mentioned 8x
"I purchased the Divine Mercy Triptych and was amazed at how beautiful and well made the item was. It took my breathe away."
Engraved items can be high quality Mentioned 3x
"I ordered an engraved Bible and an engraved Rosary for my grandsons confirmation. Absolutely beautiful."
Easy to navigate website and ordering process Mentioned 3x
"Easy to shop and find the items I was interested in. Easy to purchase. No problems at all."
Occasional instances of helpful customer service Mentioned 3x
"I was getting help for a product that I received with a faulty defect, and the Customer Service on the live chat was excellent!"

Common Complaints

Frequent shipping delays and lost packages Mentioned 30x
"I ordered over $244. worth of various items on September 9, 2025. After a month the tracking number still said 'label created'. I emailed and was told the package was 'lost'."
Poor customer service and lack of responsiveness Mentioned 28x
"Customer support is non existent except for useless bots: USPS delivered my goods to the wrong address and the company refuses to respond to my help requests to get a refund."
Inconsistent product quality and misrepresentation Mentioned 25x
"Extremely poor quality products. Purchased a plug-in eternity candle when my mother passed. It lasted 6 months before shorting out."
Customers are required to pay for return shipping, even for defective items Mentioned 10x
"Shipping was $7 and when I went to return it they informed me that I would also be required to pay for return shipping. Essentially making my net refund 50% back from the original cost."
Promo codes not always applied correctly Mentioned 3x
"I ordered from Catholic Company and included a promo code. When I received my emailed receipt, the percentage off from code was not subtracted."

Common Questions About Catholiccompany

Answers derived from customer review patterns

Is Catholiccompany legit and trustworthy?

Catholiccompany.com has a Trustpilot rating of 3.3/5, indicating mixed customer experiences. While some customers praise the quality of their products and the ease of shopping, a significant number report issues with shipping delays, poor customer service, and discrepancies in product quality. Several reviewers mention difficulties in contacting customer support and receiving refunds for damaged or undelivered items. Therefore, while Catholiccompany offers a wide selection of Catholic items, potential customers should proceed with caution and be aware of the potential risks.

Based on 45 reviews

Does Catholiccompany have good customer service?

Customer service is a significant point of contention for Catholiccompany. Many reviewers report negative experiences, citing unresponsiveness, difficulty contacting representatives, and unhelpful support when issues arise. Some customers mention that their emails and calls went unanswered, while others describe interactions with bots or unhelpful representatives. However, a few reviewers report positive experiences with customer service, indicating that the quality of support can vary.

Based on 28 reviews

Is Catholiccompany worth it for small business?

For small businesses, Catholiccompany presents a mixed bag. The wide selection of Catholic items could be appealing for businesses needing religious products or gifts. However, the reported issues with shipping delays, inconsistent product quality, and poor customer service raise concerns about reliability. Small businesses that require consistent and dependable service may want to consider alternative suppliers with more positive and reliable customer feedback.

Based on 15 reviews

What is Catholiccompany's return policy like?

Catholiccompany's return policy allows returns within 30 days, but many reviewers express frustration with the return process. A common complaint is that customers are required to pay for return shipping, even when the issue is the company's fault, such as receiving a damaged or defective item. Some customers also report receiving only partial refunds or having difficulty obtaining refunds altogether, making the return process potentially costly and inconvenient.

Based on 10 reviews

Why are there complaints about product quality at Catholiccompany?

Several reviewers complain about the poor quality of products, stating that items received were not as advertised or were damaged upon arrival. Some customers mention discrepancies in product descriptions, such as medals not being sterling silver as claimed, while others report issues with engraving quality and overall craftsmanship. These inconsistencies in product quality contribute to customer dissatisfaction and raise concerns about the reliability of the company's offerings.

Based on 25 reviews

Ready to Try Catholiccompany?

Save on your first purchase with 2 verified coupon codes.

View Coupons

Looking for Something Different?

Compare Catholiccompany against 24 similar lifestyle & perks options.

View Alternatives